Month: January 2017

January 9, 2017

 

It’s on to Draft #2.5 for me! Time for revisions, revisions, and more revisions. I’m certain I’m not the first, and I definitely won’t be the last, to tell you how important revising and editing your drafts are.

 

For the longest time though, moving past the first draft was the hardest part for me. I could write first draft after first draft (NaNoWriMo had trained me well), but would never revisit the story after I’d typed “The End.” And if the goal is to be published one day, you cannot stop after “The End.” There is so much more work to do!

 

Part of that work, once you feel comfortable, is to ask for feedback. And that’s what I want to share with y’all today. Below is the note I sent my first reader, detailed what they can expect, where I’d like them to focus, and any expectations I have regarding a review. (Don’t forget to profusely thank your friends for willingly reading a draft not in its best version! And if they’re also writers, volunteer to do the same for them when they’re ready!)

 


 

Note to Start

This is a first draft, which means you will find:

    • Typos
    • Rhythm/flow issues
    • Tense changes
    • Other grammar problems

I don’t want you focusing on these things, though! (At least, not right now…!)

If you’re like me, and it’s just TOO MUCH to not correct something, just mark through it! I’ll read over all of your notes and can figure it out.

The reason I encourage not focusing attention on grammatical errors is because this is the easiest change to make! I need your help on the BIG things. Which leads me to…

 

Where to Focus

  • Plotting
    • Do you like the plot? Do some scenes need more explaining? Do some scenes not make any sense? Do you just plain not like a scene (as a reader)? Do the subplots fit in the main plot, and add to it?
  • Pacing
    • Not to be confused with rhythm/flow of each individual sentence
    • This is a bigger view. Does the pacing make sense within the chapter? Across a series of chapters? Not enough ramp-up to big events? Too much ramp-up and then the actual event happens too quickly? That kind of thing!
  • Character Development
    • This goes for main characters to supporting/minor characters
      • Believability?
        • Could there actually be someone like this? If not, is it at least amusing/add to the story?
      • Likability?
        • This is especially important for main characters! They need to be rooted for or, at least, something felt for them. Most important (to me) is that they’re not annoying.
      • Consistency?
        • Does this decision make sense for this character?
      • Growth?
        • Do the characters seem like they’ve grown over the course of the story?
      • Dimensionality?
        • This is a first draft, so I know there will be plenty of issues with this, especially in more minor characters!
  • Story Arcs
    • Main plots and subplots
      • Are there enough subplots? Do the subplots make sense within the story? Could you have guessed how the story was going from the beginning?
  • Major Inconsistencies
    • Were major or minor plot points abandoned? Did one character say something only to contradict it, without explanation, later? Does something just NOT MAKE SENSE?
  • Additions/Deletions
    • Do you see a place for the story to expand? Were you curious about something that wasn’t in the first draft, but you think should be? Were there scenes that could have been longer? Conversely, were there scenes that didn’t move the plot forward or seemed unimportant?
  • YOUR OPINION/OTHER IMPORTANT THINGS
    • Does the writing style come through? (Since I’m writing from first person, can you tell that the Main Character has a clear VOICE)?
    • What do you think of the work as a whole, after finishing? Were all of your questions answered? Was everything tied together well enough? Since I imagine this as a sequel, would you be okay with the ending enough even though you have to wait a year for the next one (or does it seem like it could “stand alone” for a period of time)?
    • Is this story marketable? Who do you think will read this/who would you recommend this to?

Comment Frequency

Feel free to take notes whenever or wherever you want, but my expectations are just a few notes at the end of each chapter and then maybe a written page-length at the end of the story to summarize your feelings and answer the questions above. They can be real quick jots and I’ll follow-up, if needed.

 

Finally,…

You da best!! Thank you so, so much for agreeing to read my “zero/first” draft! I value your opinion and really appreciate you taking the time to look over this. I hope it’s the first of many! <3

 


 

Okay, there you have it! This gives your reader plenty to focus on, and a much better idea of what kind of feedback you’re hoping to receive than “just read it and tell me what you think, mmkay?” Good luck to everyone working on their first/second/third/millionth draft! We’ve got this!

 

What has been the hardest part for you? Hitting “The End”? Revising? Draft #10? Querying? Let me know!